[
  {
    "canonicalClaimUrl": "https://xn--mwe.com/research/preemptive-cyber-operations-known-threat-groups/#clm-k04-rep-043-f01",
    "claimStatus": "RESEARCH FINDING",
    "correctionStatus": "CURRENT K04 RECORD",
    "id": "CLM-K04-REP-043-F01",
    "lastReviewed": "2026-08-16",
    "machineRecordUrl": "https://xn--mwe.com/data/claims/clm-k04-rep-043-f01.json",
    "name": "The Strategic and Legal Dimensions of Preemptive Cyber Operations Against Known Threat Groups: A Global Perspective — finding 1",
    "ownerAnchor": "clm-k04-rep-043-f01",
    "ownerId": "REP-K04-043",
    "ownerRoute": "/research/preemptive-cyber-operations-known-threat-groups/",
    "ownerType": "report",
    "proposition": "The report argues that speed, attacker advantage, covert persistence, and dormant access can make perimeter-only defense insufficient against known cyber threat groups.",
    "qualification": "The source advances arguments in favor of proactive cyber operations and surveys national doctrines. K04 preserves the strategic case while separating it from current legal authorization, verified intelligence, rules of engagement, target approval, and primary-source validation of time-sensitive national policies.",
    "releaseId": "K12-2026-08-16",
    "releaseVersion": "2.1.0",
    "researchCutoff": "2026-08-16",
    "scope": "Governed finding 1 from report REP-K04-043; public reliance is limited to the report synthesis, source hash, correction state, and stated project claim status.",
    "slug": "clm-k04-rep-043-f01",
    "sourceIds": [],
    "sourceReport": {
      "filename": "preemptive-cyber-operations-justifications.md",
      "id": "REP-K04-043",
      "originalFilename": "Preemptive Cyber Attack Justifications(1).md",
      "sha256": "02e012557c47ad34b39229eeb674772cf4b61b1c601e0d6d96232f64e80e786c",
      "sizeBytes": 56022
    },
    "sourceSections": [
      {
        "section": "Introduction to Proactive Cyber Operations",
        "sourceFilename": "preemptive-cyber-operations-justifications.md",
        "sourceReportId": "REP-K04-043",
        "sourceSha256": "02e012557c47ad34b39229eeb674772cf4b61b1c601e0d6d96232f64e80e786c",
        "supportRelationship": "GOVERNED REPORT FINDING"
      }
    ],
    "type": "ClaimRecord"
  },
  {
    "canonicalClaimUrl": "https://xn--mwe.com/research/preemptive-cyber-operations-known-threat-groups/#clm-k04-rep-043-f02",
    "claimStatus": "RESEARCH FINDING",
    "correctionStatus": "CURRENT K04 RECORD",
    "id": "CLM-K04-REP-043-F02",
    "lastReviewed": "2026-08-16",
    "machineRecordUrl": "https://xn--mwe.com/data/claims/clm-k04-rep-043-f02.json",
    "name": "The Strategic and Legal Dimensions of Preemptive Cyber Operations Against Known Threat Groups: A Global Perspective — finding 2",
    "ownerAnchor": "clm-k04-rep-043-f02",
    "ownerId": "REP-K04-043",
    "ownerRoute": "/research/preemptive-cyber-operations-known-threat-groups/",
    "ownerType": "report",
    "proposition": "It states that Article 51 analysis depends on whether the prospective cyber effects would reach the scale and effects of an armed attack, while espionage, theft, and lower-level disruption often remain below that threshold.",
    "qualification": "The source advances arguments in favor of proactive cyber operations and surveys national doctrines. K04 preserves the strategic case while separating it from current legal authorization, verified intelligence, rules of engagement, target approval, and primary-source validation of time-sensitive national policies.",
    "releaseId": "K12-2026-08-16",
    "releaseVersion": "2.1.0",
    "researchCutoff": "2026-08-16",
    "scope": "Governed finding 2 from report REP-K04-043; public reliance is limited to the report synthesis, source hash, correction state, and stated project claim status.",
    "slug": "clm-k04-rep-043-f02",
    "sourceIds": [],
    "sourceReport": {
      "filename": "preemptive-cyber-operations-justifications.md",
      "id": "REP-K04-043",
      "originalFilename": "Preemptive Cyber Attack Justifications(1).md",
      "sha256": "02e012557c47ad34b39229eeb674772cf4b61b1c601e0d6d96232f64e80e786c",
      "sizeBytes": 56022
    },
    "sourceSections": [
      {
        "section": "The Evolving Threat Landscape: The Rise of Non-State Actors and Known Groups",
        "sourceFilename": "preemptive-cyber-operations-justifications.md",
        "sourceReportId": "REP-K04-043",
        "sourceSha256": "02e012557c47ad34b39229eeb674772cf4b61b1c601e0d6d96232f64e80e786c",
        "supportRelationship": "GOVERNED REPORT FINDING"
      }
    ],
    "type": "ClaimRecord"
  },
  {
    "canonicalClaimUrl": "https://xn--mwe.com/research/preemptive-cyber-operations-known-threat-groups/#clm-k04-rep-043-f03",
    "claimStatus": "RESEARCH FINDING",
    "correctionStatus": "CURRENT K04 RECORD",
    "id": "CLM-K04-REP-043-F03",
    "lastReviewed": "2026-08-16",
    "machineRecordUrl": "https://xn--mwe.com/data/claims/clm-k04-rep-043-f03.json",
    "name": "The Strategic and Legal Dimensions of Preemptive Cyber Operations Against Known Threat Groups: A Global Perspective — finding 3",
    "ownerAnchor": "clm-k04-rep-043-f03",
    "ownerId": "REP-K04-043",
    "ownerRoute": "/research/preemptive-cyber-operations-known-threat-groups/",
    "ownerType": "report",
    "proposition": "It identifies cumulative effects as a contested method for evaluating sustained campaigns whose individual operations may remain below an armed-attack threshold.",
    "qualification": "The source advances arguments in favor of proactive cyber operations and surveys national doctrines. K04 preserves the strategic case while separating it from current legal authorization, verified intelligence, rules of engagement, target approval, and primary-source validation of time-sensitive national policies.",
    "releaseId": "K12-2026-08-16",
    "releaseVersion": "2.1.0",
    "researchCutoff": "2026-08-16",
    "scope": "Governed finding 3 from report REP-K04-043; public reliance is limited to the report synthesis, source hash, correction state, and stated project claim status.",
    "slug": "clm-k04-rep-043-f03",
    "sourceIds": [],
    "sourceReport": {
      "filename": "preemptive-cyber-operations-justifications.md",
      "id": "REP-K04-043",
      "originalFilename": "Preemptive Cyber Attack Justifications(1).md",
      "sha256": "02e012557c47ad34b39229eeb674772cf4b61b1c601e0d6d96232f64e80e786c",
      "sizeBytes": 56022
    },
    "sourceSections": [
      {
        "section": "The Blurring of State and Non-State Actors",
        "sourceFilename": "preemptive-cyber-operations-justifications.md",
        "sourceReportId": "REP-K04-043",
        "sourceSha256": "02e012557c47ad34b39229eeb674772cf4b61b1c601e0d6d96232f64e80e786c",
        "supportRelationship": "GOVERNED REPORT FINDING"
      }
    ],
    "type": "ClaimRecord"
  },
  {
    "canonicalClaimUrl": "https://xn--mwe.com/research/preemptive-cyber-operations-known-threat-groups/#clm-k04-rep-043-f04",
    "claimStatus": "RESEARCH FINDING",
    "correctionStatus": "CURRENT K04 RECORD",
    "id": "CLM-K04-REP-043-F04",
    "lastReviewed": "2026-08-16",
    "machineRecordUrl": "https://xn--mwe.com/data/claims/clm-k04-rep-043-f04.json",
    "name": "The Strategic and Legal Dimensions of Preemptive Cyber Operations Against Known Threat Groups: A Global Perspective — finding 4",
    "ownerAnchor": "clm-k04-rep-043-f04",
    "ownerId": "REP-K04-043",
    "ownerRoute": "/research/preemptive-cyber-operations-known-threat-groups/",
    "ownerType": "report",
    "proposition": "It applies contextual imminence and the last-possible-window concept to circumstances in which waiting for a final activation command would eliminate the defender's practical ability to prevent catastrophic effects.",
    "qualification": "The source advances arguments in favor of proactive cyber operations and surveys national doctrines. K04 preserves the strategic case while separating it from current legal authorization, verified intelligence, rules of engagement, target approval, and primary-source validation of time-sensitive national policies.",
    "releaseId": "K12-2026-08-16",
    "releaseVersion": "2.1.0",
    "researchCutoff": "2026-08-16",
    "scope": "Governed finding 4 from report REP-K04-043; public reliance is limited to the report synthesis, source hash, correction state, and stated project claim status.",
    "slug": "clm-k04-rep-043-f04",
    "sourceIds": [],
    "sourceReport": {
      "filename": "preemptive-cyber-operations-justifications.md",
      "id": "REP-K04-043",
      "originalFilename": "Preemptive Cyber Attack Justifications(1).md",
      "sha256": "02e012557c47ad34b39229eeb674772cf4b61b1c601e0d6d96232f64e80e786c",
      "sizeBytes": 56022
    },
    "sourceSections": [
      {
        "section": "The Inadequacy of Perimeter Defense",
        "sourceFilename": "preemptive-cyber-operations-justifications.md",
        "sourceReportId": "REP-K04-043",
        "sourceSha256": "02e012557c47ad34b39229eeb674772cf4b61b1c601e0d6d96232f64e80e786c",
        "supportRelationship": "GOVERNED REPORT FINDING"
      }
    ],
    "type": "ClaimRecord"
  },
  {
    "canonicalClaimUrl": "https://xn--mwe.com/research/preemptive-cyber-operations-known-threat-groups/#clm-k04-rep-043-f05",
    "claimStatus": "RESEARCH FINDING",
    "correctionStatus": "CURRENT K04 RECORD",
    "id": "CLM-K04-REP-043-F05",
    "lastReviewed": "2026-08-16",
    "machineRecordUrl": "https://xn--mwe.com/data/claims/clm-k04-rep-043-f05.json",
    "name": "The Strategic and Legal Dimensions of Preemptive Cyber Operations Against Known Threat Groups: A Global Perspective — finding 5",
    "ownerAnchor": "clm-k04-rep-043-f05",
    "ownerId": "REP-K04-043",
    "ownerRoute": "/research/preemptive-cyber-operations-known-threat-groups/",
    "ownerType": "report",
    "proposition": "It identifies capability, verifiable hostile intent, target access, and exhaustion or inadequacy of timely alternatives as necessary evidence categories for any anticipatory cyber-defense claim.",
    "qualification": "The source advances arguments in favor of proactive cyber operations and surveys national doctrines. K04 preserves the strategic case while separating it from current legal authorization, verified intelligence, rules of engagement, target approval, and primary-source validation of time-sensitive national policies.",
    "releaseId": "K12-2026-08-16",
    "releaseVersion": "2.1.0",
    "researchCutoff": "2026-08-16",
    "scope": "Governed finding 5 from report REP-K04-043; public reliance is limited to the report synthesis, source hash, correction state, and stated project claim status.",
    "slug": "clm-k04-rep-043-f05",
    "sourceIds": [],
    "sourceReport": {
      "filename": "preemptive-cyber-operations-justifications.md",
      "id": "REP-K04-043",
      "originalFilename": "Preemptive Cyber Attack Justifications(1).md",
      "sha256": "02e012557c47ad34b39229eeb674772cf4b61b1c601e0d6d96232f64e80e786c",
      "sizeBytes": 56022
    },
    "sourceSections": [
      {
        "section": "The International Legal Framework: Anticipatory Self-Defense in Cyberspace",
        "sourceFilename": "preemptive-cyber-operations-justifications.md",
        "sourceReportId": "REP-K04-043",
        "sourceSha256": "02e012557c47ad34b39229eeb674772cf4b61b1c601e0d6d96232f64e80e786c",
        "supportRelationship": "GOVERNED REPORT FINDING"
      }
    ],
    "type": "ClaimRecord"
  },
  {
    "canonicalClaimUrl": "https://xn--mwe.com/research/preemptive-cyber-operations-known-threat-groups/#clm-k04-rep-043-f06",
    "claimStatus": "RESEARCH FINDING",
    "correctionStatus": "CURRENT K04 RECORD",
    "id": "CLM-K04-REP-043-F06",
    "lastReviewed": "2026-08-16",
    "machineRecordUrl": "https://xn--mwe.com/data/claims/clm-k04-rep-043-f06.json",
    "name": "The Strategic and Legal Dimensions of Preemptive Cyber Operations Against Known Threat Groups: A Global Perspective — finding 6",
    "ownerAnchor": "clm-k04-rep-043-f06",
    "ownerId": "REP-K04-043",
    "ownerRoute": "/research/preemptive-cyber-operations-known-threat-groups/",
    "ownerType": "report",
    "proposition": "It distinguishes action against a non-state threat group from attribution of that group to a host state and treats unable-or-unwilling reasoning as legally controversial rather than automatically dispositive.",
    "qualification": "The source advances arguments in favor of proactive cyber operations and surveys national doctrines. K04 preserves the strategic case while separating it from current legal authorization, verified intelligence, rules of engagement, target approval, and primary-source validation of time-sensitive national policies.",
    "releaseId": "K12-2026-08-16",
    "releaseVersion": "2.1.0",
    "researchCutoff": "2026-08-16",
    "scope": "Governed finding 6 from report REP-K04-043; public reliance is limited to the report synthesis, source hash, correction state, and stated project claim status.",
    "slug": "clm-k04-rep-043-f06",
    "sourceIds": [],
    "sourceReport": {
      "filename": "preemptive-cyber-operations-justifications.md",
      "id": "REP-K04-043",
      "originalFilename": "Preemptive Cyber Attack Justifications(1).md",
      "sha256": "02e012557c47ad34b39229eeb674772cf4b61b1c601e0d6d96232f64e80e786c",
      "sizeBytes": 56022
    },
    "sourceSections": [
      {
        "section": "The Threshold of an \"Armed Attack\"",
        "sourceFilename": "preemptive-cyber-operations-justifications.md",
        "sourceReportId": "REP-K04-043",
        "sourceSha256": "02e012557c47ad34b39229eeb674772cf4b61b1c601e0d6d96232f64e80e786c",
        "supportRelationship": "GOVERNED REPORT FINDING"
      }
    ],
    "type": "ClaimRecord"
  },
  {
    "canonicalClaimUrl": "https://xn--mwe.com/research/preemptive-cyber-operations-known-threat-groups/#clm-k04-rep-043-f07",
    "claimStatus": "RESEARCH FINDING",
    "correctionStatus": "CURRENT K04 RECORD",
    "id": "CLM-K04-REP-043-F07",
    "lastReviewed": "2026-08-16",
    "machineRecordUrl": "https://xn--mwe.com/data/claims/clm-k04-rep-043-f07.json",
    "name": "The Strategic and Legal Dimensions of Preemptive Cyber Operations Against Known Threat Groups: A Global Perspective — finding 7",
    "ownerAnchor": "clm-k04-rep-043-f07",
    "ownerId": "REP-K04-043",
    "ownerRoute": "/research/preemptive-cyber-operations-known-threat-groups/",
    "ownerType": "report",
    "proposition": "It presents persistent engagement and deterrence by denial as strategic approaches intended to impose continuing friction and deny adversary freedom of action.",
    "qualification": "The source advances arguments in favor of proactive cyber operations and surveys national doctrines. K04 preserves the strategic case while separating it from current legal authorization, verified intelligence, rules of engagement, target approval, and primary-source validation of time-sensitive national policies.",
    "releaseId": "K12-2026-08-16",
    "releaseVersion": "2.1.0",
    "researchCutoff": "2026-08-16",
    "scope": "Governed finding 7 from report REP-K04-043; public reliance is limited to the report synthesis, source hash, correction state, and stated project claim status.",
    "slug": "clm-k04-rep-043-f07",
    "sourceIds": [],
    "sourceReport": {
      "filename": "preemptive-cyber-operations-justifications.md",
      "id": "REP-K04-043",
      "originalFilename": "Preemptive Cyber Attack Justifications(1).md",
      "sha256": "02e012557c47ad34b39229eeb674772cf4b61b1c601e0d6d96232f64e80e786c",
      "sizeBytes": 56022
    },
    "sourceSections": [
      {
        "section": "The Caroline Doctrine and Anticipatory Self-Defense",
        "sourceFilename": "preemptive-cyber-operations-justifications.md",
        "sourceReportId": "REP-K04-043",
        "sourceSha256": "02e012557c47ad34b39229eeb674772cf4b61b1c601e0d6d96232f64e80e786c",
        "supportRelationship": "GOVERNED REPORT FINDING"
      }
    ],
    "type": "ClaimRecord"
  },
  {
    "canonicalClaimUrl": "https://xn--mwe.com/research/preemptive-cyber-operations-known-threat-groups/#clm-k04-rep-043-f08",
    "claimStatus": "RESEARCH FINDING",
    "correctionStatus": "CURRENT K04 RECORD",
    "id": "CLM-K04-REP-043-F08",
    "lastReviewed": "2026-08-16",
    "machineRecordUrl": "https://xn--mwe.com/data/claims/clm-k04-rep-043-f08.json",
    "name": "The Strategic and Legal Dimensions of Preemptive Cyber Operations Against Known Threat Groups: A Global Perspective — finding 8",
    "ownerAnchor": "clm-k04-rep-043-f08",
    "ownerId": "REP-K04-043",
    "ownerRoute": "/research/preemptive-cyber-operations-known-threat-groups/",
    "ownerType": "report",
    "proposition": "It surveys divergent national approaches ranging from continuous proactive operations to constitutional and legal restrictions on hack-back and extraterritorial disruption.",
    "qualification": "The source advances arguments in favor of proactive cyber operations and surveys national doctrines. K04 preserves the strategic case while separating it from current legal authorization, verified intelligence, rules of engagement, target approval, and primary-source validation of time-sensitive national policies.",
    "releaseId": "K12-2026-08-16",
    "releaseVersion": "2.1.0",
    "researchCutoff": "2026-08-16",
    "scope": "Governed finding 8 from report REP-K04-043; public reliance is limited to the report synthesis, source hash, correction state, and stated project claim status.",
    "slug": "clm-k04-rep-043-f08",
    "sourceIds": [],
    "sourceReport": {
      "filename": "preemptive-cyber-operations-justifications.md",
      "id": "REP-K04-043",
      "originalFilename": "Preemptive Cyber Attack Justifications(1).md",
      "sha256": "02e012557c47ad34b39229eeb674772cf4b61b1c601e0d6d96232f64e80e786c",
      "sizeBytes": 56022
    },
    "sourceSections": [
      {
        "section": "Redefining Imminence: The \"Last Possible Window of Opportunity\"",
        "sourceFilename": "preemptive-cyber-operations-justifications.md",
        "sourceReportId": "REP-K04-043",
        "sourceSha256": "02e012557c47ad34b39229eeb674772cf4b61b1c601e0d6d96232f64e80e786c",
        "supportRelationship": "GOVERNED REPORT FINDING"
      }
    ],
    "type": "ClaimRecord"
  },
  {
    "canonicalClaimUrl": "https://xn--mwe.com/research/preemptive-cyber-operations-known-threat-groups/#clm-k04-rep-043-f09",
    "claimStatus": "RESEARCH FINDING",
    "correctionStatus": "CURRENT K04 RECORD",
    "id": "CLM-K04-REP-043-F09",
    "lastReviewed": "2026-08-16",
    "machineRecordUrl": "https://xn--mwe.com/data/claims/clm-k04-rep-043-f09.json",
    "name": "The Strategic and Legal Dimensions of Preemptive Cyber Operations Against Known Threat Groups: A Global Perspective — finding 9",
    "ownerAnchor": "clm-k04-rep-043-f09",
    "ownerId": "REP-K04-043",
    "ownerRoute": "/research/preemptive-cyber-operations-known-threat-groups/",
    "ownerType": "report",
    "proposition": "It identifies mistaken attribution, third-party infrastructure damage, intelligence exposure, sovereignty violations, and unintended escalation as principal failure modes.",
    "qualification": "The source advances arguments in favor of proactive cyber operations and surveys national doctrines. K04 preserves the strategic case while separating it from current legal authorization, verified intelligence, rules of engagement, target approval, and primary-source validation of time-sensitive national policies.",
    "releaseId": "K12-2026-08-16",
    "releaseVersion": "2.1.0",
    "researchCutoff": "2026-08-16",
    "scope": "Governed finding 9 from report REP-K04-043; public reliance is limited to the report synthesis, source hash, correction state, and stated project claim status.",
    "slug": "clm-k04-rep-043-f09",
    "sourceIds": [],
    "sourceReport": {
      "filename": "preemptive-cyber-operations-justifications.md",
      "id": "REP-K04-043",
      "originalFilename": "Preemptive Cyber Attack Justifications(1).md",
      "sha256": "02e012557c47ad34b39229eeb674772cf4b61b1c601e0d6d96232f64e80e786c",
      "sizeBytes": 56022
    },
    "sourceSections": [
      {
        "section": "Preempting Non-State Actors and the Sovereignty Dilemma",
        "sourceFilename": "preemptive-cyber-operations-justifications.md",
        "sourceReportId": "REP-K04-043",
        "sourceSha256": "02e012557c47ad34b39229eeb674772cf4b61b1c601e0d6d96232f64e80e786c",
        "supportRelationship": "GOVERNED REPORT FINDING"
      }
    ],
    "type": "ClaimRecord"
  },
  {
    "canonicalClaimUrl": "https://xn--mwe.com/research/preemptive-cyber-operations-known-threat-groups/#clm-k04-rep-043-f10",
    "claimStatus": "RESEARCH FINDING",
    "correctionStatus": "CURRENT K04 RECORD",
    "id": "CLM-K04-REP-043-F10",
    "lastReviewed": "2026-08-16",
    "machineRecordUrl": "https://xn--mwe.com/data/claims/clm-k04-rep-043-f10.json",
    "name": "The Strategic and Legal Dimensions of Preemptive Cyber Operations Against Known Threat Groups: A Global Perspective — finding 10",
    "ownerAnchor": "clm-k04-rep-043-f10",
    "ownerId": "REP-K04-043",
    "ownerRoute": "/research/preemptive-cyber-operations-known-threat-groups/",
    "ownerType": "report",
    "proposition": "K04 treats consent-based hunt-forward activity, law-enforcement disruption, countermeasures, self-defense, and unconsented offensive operations as distinct legal and operational categories.",
    "qualification": "The source advances arguments in favor of proactive cyber operations and surveys national doctrines. K04 preserves the strategic case while separating it from current legal authorization, verified intelligence, rules of engagement, target approval, and primary-source validation of time-sensitive national policies.",
    "releaseId": "K12-2026-08-16",
    "releaseVersion": "2.1.0",
    "researchCutoff": "2026-08-16",
    "scope": "Governed finding 10 from report REP-K04-043; public reliance is limited to the report synthesis, source hash, correction state, and stated project claim status.",
    "slug": "clm-k04-rep-043-f10",
    "sourceIds": [],
    "sourceReport": {
      "filename": "preemptive-cyber-operations-justifications.md",
      "id": "REP-K04-043",
      "originalFilename": "Preemptive Cyber Attack Justifications(1).md",
      "sha256": "02e012557c47ad34b39229eeb674772cf4b61b1c601e0d6d96232f64e80e786c",
      "sizeBytes": 56022
    },
    "sourceSections": [
      {
        "section": "Strategic Rationales: Moving Beyond Deterrence by Punishment",
        "sourceFilename": "preemptive-cyber-operations-justifications.md",
        "sourceReportId": "REP-K04-043",
        "sourceSha256": "02e012557c47ad34b39229eeb674772cf4b61b1c601e0d6d96232f64e80e786c",
        "supportRelationship": "GOVERNED REPORT FINDING"
      }
    ],
    "type": "ClaimRecord"
  },
  {
    "canonicalClaimUrl": "https://xn--mwe.com/research/preemptive-cyber-operations-known-threat-groups/#clm-k04-rep-043-f11",
    "claimStatus": "RESEARCH FINDING",
    "correctionStatus": "CURRENT K04 RECORD",
    "id": "CLM-K04-REP-043-F11",
    "lastReviewed": "2026-08-16",
    "machineRecordUrl": "https://xn--mwe.com/data/claims/clm-k04-rep-043-f11.json",
    "name": "The Strategic and Legal Dimensions of Preemptive Cyber Operations Against Known Threat Groups: A Global Perspective — finding 11",
    "ownerAnchor": "clm-k04-rep-043-f11",
    "ownerId": "REP-K04-043",
    "ownerRoute": "/research/preemptive-cyber-operations-known-threat-groups/",
    "ownerType": "report",
    "proposition": "The report does not itself authorize an operation, establish imminence, identify a lawful target, or substitute for current intelligence, competent authority, legal review, and mission-specific safeguards.",
    "qualification": "The source advances arguments in favor of proactive cyber operations and surveys national doctrines. K04 preserves the strategic case while separating it from current legal authorization, verified intelligence, rules of engagement, target approval, and primary-source validation of time-sensitive national policies.",
    "releaseId": "K12-2026-08-16",
    "releaseVersion": "2.1.0",
    "researchCutoff": "2026-08-16",
    "scope": "Governed finding 11 from report REP-K04-043; public reliance is limited to the report synthesis, source hash, correction state, and stated project claim status.",
    "slug": "clm-k04-rep-043-f11",
    "sourceIds": [],
    "sourceReport": {
      "filename": "preemptive-cyber-operations-justifications.md",
      "id": "REP-K04-043",
      "originalFilename": "Preemptive Cyber Attack Justifications(1).md",
      "sha256": "02e012557c47ad34b39229eeb674772cf4b61b1c601e0d6d96232f64e80e786c",
      "sizeBytes": 56022
    },
    "sourceSections": [
      {
        "section": "Global Doctrines and Case Studies: The Framing of Preemption",
        "sourceFilename": "preemptive-cyber-operations-justifications.md",
        "sourceReportId": "REP-K04-043",
        "sourceSha256": "02e012557c47ad34b39229eeb674772cf4b61b1c601e0d6d96232f64e80e786c",
        "supportRelationship": "GOVERNED REPORT FINDING"
      }
    ],
    "type": "ClaimRecord"
  }
]